Eggnog Recipes

25+ Eggnog Desserts for Holiday Parties, Cozy Bakes, and Sweet Treats

Millie Pham

A carton of eggnog can do more than fill a holiday mug. Its creamy sweetness and warm spice fit into cakes, cookies, chilled desserts, and small treats for sharing. These eggnog desserts give you plenty of ways to bring that familiar flavor to the table, whether you enjoy a rich cheesecake or a soft cookie.

There are make-ahead choices for busy gatherings, warm bakes for quiet evenings, and a few sweet brunch ideas worth keeping nearby. Choose something that suits your schedule, check the linked recipe for its full instructions, and leave time for any cooling or chilling before serving.

25+ Easy Eggnog Desserts for Holiday PartiesPin

1. Eggnog Cheesecake Crumble Bars

Eggnog Cheesecake Crumble BarsPin

A graham cracker crust gives these bars a firm buttery base beneath creamy eggnog cheesecake. Brown sugar, butter, cinnamon, and nutmeg make a crumbly topping that adds texture without hiding the filling. Bake the layers together, then chill before slicing. These are a useful choice when you want cheesecake in smaller portions for sharing.

Try these eggnog cheesecake crumble bars.

2. Eggnog Cheesecake

Eggnog CheesecakePin

Eggnog and cream cheese make a rich filling over a buttery graham cracker crust. Nutmeg adds warmth, while a dusting on top keeps the finish light. This baked cheesecake needs a slow cool and a long chill, so plan to make it ahead. Serve small slices after dinner or alongside coffee at a holiday gathering.

Make this creamy eggnog cheesecake.

3. Eggnog Crème Brûlée

Eggnog Crème BrûléePin

Smooth eggnog custard meets a thin, delicately crisp sugar shell in this individual dessert. Cream, egg yolks, vanilla, and nutmeg give the filling its richness. A gentle water bath helps the custard bake evenly before chilling. Caramelize the sugar shortly before serving so each spoonful starts with a crack and ends with cool cream.

Follow this eggnog crème brûlée recipe.

4. Eggnog Cupcakes

Eggnog CupcakesPin

Eggnog flavors both the soft cupcake batter and the creamy buttercream, with nutmeg adding a gentle holiday note. Let the cakes cool completely before piping the frosting so the swirls hold their shape. Individual portions make these easy to arrange on a dessert tray, and you can leave a few plain for a simpler serving.

Bake these frosted eggnog cupcakes.

5. Eggnog Cream Puffs

Eggnog Cream PuffsPin

Light pastry shells hold a cool, smooth eggnog filling in these small cream puffs. Whipped cream softens the filling, while nutmeg brings out its seasonal flavor. A little powdered sugar finishes the tops without a heavy icing. Prepare the parts ahead, then fill close to serving to keep the shells crisp against the creamy centers.

Assemble these eggnog cream puffs.

6. Eggnog Mousse

Eggnog MoussePin

Whipped cream gives this eggnog mousse an airy texture, while a small amount of gelatin helps it set in dessert glasses. Vanilla and nutmeg round out the creamy flavor. Chill the portions ahead so dessert is ready when dinner ends, then add the gingersnaps just before serving for a crisp contrast to the soft mousse.

Spoon into this eggnog mousse.

7. Eggnog Trifle with Layered Spice Cake

Eggnog Trifle with Layered Spice CakePin

Homemade spice cake, eggnog pudding, and whipped cream stack into a spoonable dessert with varied texture. Cinnamon and ginger warm the cake, while the pudding keeps the layers moist. A clear bowl lets the different layers show without careful decorating. Assemble ahead to give the cake time to soften before bringing it to the table.

Build this layered eggnog trifle.

8. Old-Fashioned Eggnog Fudge

Old-Fashioned Eggnog FudgePin

White chocolate and marshmallow creme turn a cooked eggnog sugar base into soft candy squares. Nutmeg and rum extract add holiday flavor without a complicated topping. Use a candy thermometer for the stovetop stage, then let the slab set fully before cutting. Small pieces work well on a dessert plate or tucked into gift boxes.

Prepare this old-fashioned eggnog fudge.

9. Eggnog Cookies with Nutmeg Frosting

Eggnog Cookies with Nutmeg FrostingPin

These cookies carry eggnog in the dough and buttercream, with cinnamon and nutmeg adding gentle spice. A short chill makes the dough easier to portion before baking. Once the cookies are completely cool, spread on the frosting and finish with nutmeg. They bring a creamy change of pace to a tray of crisp holiday cookies.

Try these frosted eggnog cookies.

10. Eggnog Bread Pudding

Eggnog Bread PuddingPin

Day-old cinnamon-raisin bread soaks up eggnog custard before baking into a tender pudding with golden edges. The raisins add pockets of sweetness, and a maple syrup drizzle finishes each warm serving. Give the bread time to absorb the liquid, then let the baked dish rest before portioning. It is a comforting option for a dessert.

Bake this eggnog bread pudding.

11. Egg Nog Cheesecake Dip

Egg Nog Cheesecake DipPin

Cream cheese brings a tang to this fluffy eggnog dip, while whipped cream keeps it soft enough for scooping. Nutmeg adds warmth without covering the dairy flavor. There is no crust or baking step, making it handy when the oven is full. Chill the bowl ahead and serve with cookies or fruit for dipping.

Mix this egg nog cheesecake dip.

12. Eggnog Pancakes with Homemade Vanilla Syrup

Eggnog Pancakes with Homemade Vanilla SyrupPin

These pancakes bring eggnog and nutmeg to a batter, creating soft centers beneath golden surfaces. A homemade vanilla syrup adds a sweet finish using pantry ingredients. Make the syrup first so it can cool slightly while you cook the pancakes. Although suited to brunch, a stack also fits a sweet holiday breakfast spread.

Make these eggnog pancakes with vanilla syrup.

13. Eggnog Soufflé

Eggnog SouffléPin

A thick eggnog custard base and gently folded egg whites give these soufflés their texture. Vanilla and nutmeg keep the flavor warm and familiar beneath the golden tops. Have the table ready before they finish baking, since the airy centers are best enjoyed right away. Individual servings make this a lovely ending to a holiday dinner.

Serve this eggnog soufflé.

14. Gluten-Free Eggnog Bread (with Glaze)

Gluten-Free Eggnog Bread (with Glaze)Pin

This loaf combines eggnog and nutmeg in a tender gluten-free bake, then adds a eggnog glaze. There is no yeast or rising time, and the batter mixes by hand. Let the loaf cool before glazing and slicing so the crumb holds together. Serve it in slices with coffee or add it to a dessert plate.

Bake this gluten-free eggnog bread.

15. Eggnog Cinnamon Rolls

Eggnog Cinnamon RollsPin

Soft yeast dough wraps around a brown sugar and cinnamon filling in these holiday rolls. Eggnog goes into the dough and cream cheese frosting, while nutmeg brings its flavor forward. Allow time for both rises before baking. Spread the frosting after a short rest so it settles over the warm spirals without completely melting away.

Try these eggnog cinnamon rolls.

16. Eggnog Snickerdoodle Thumbprint Cookies

Eggnog Snickerdoodle Thumbprint CookiesPin

Cinnamon sugar coats these tender thumbprint cookies, giving the edges a crisp finish. Each center holds creamy eggnog cream cheese frosting with a little nutmeg. Chill the dough before rolling, then make wells that leave room for the filling. Cool the baked cookies fully before piping, so the swirls stay neat on your plate.

Bake these eggnog snickerdoodle thumbprint cookies.

17. No-Bake Eggnog Cream Pie

No-Bake Eggnog Cream PiePin

A graham cracker crust holds a fluffy eggnog filling beneath a whipped cream topping. Nutmeg adds warmth to the cool layers, giving this pie a holiday flavor without a baked custard. A crust keeps the whole recipe out of the oven. Leave enough refrigerator time for the filling to set before cutting into slices.

Chill this no-bake eggnog cream pie.

18. Eggnog Dump Cake

Eggnog Dump CakePin

Dry white cake mix, eggnog, butter, and nutmeg go straight into the baking dish for this dessert. The ingredients stay layered rather than becoming a mixed batter, giving the finished cake a buttery crust and soft middle. Let it rest after baking, then spoon out warm portions instead of trying to cut tidy slices.

Scoop up this eggnog dump cake.

19. Eggnog Truffles

Eggnog TrufflesPin

White chocolate, cream cheese, and a little eggnog make the centers of these chilled truffles. Vanilla and nutmeg add holiday flavor before another layer of white chocolate coats each piece. Chill the filling until it is firm enough to roll, then dip the balls. Keep the finished treats refrigerated until you are ready to share them.

Make these eggnog truffles.

20. Eggnog Crumble Muffin

Eggnog Crumble MuffinPin

A buttery crumble gives these muffins a little crunch, while eggnog and nutmeg flavor the cake underneath. An eggnog glaze settles between the crumbs after the muffins cool. The batter needs only a whisk and spatula, making this an approachable bake for a afternoon. Serve them in their liners for an easy individual treat.

Try this eggnog crumble muffin recipe.

21. Eggnog Poke Cake

Eggnog Poke CakePin

Eggnog pudding sinks into holes in vanilla cake, adding creamy pockets throughout the crumb. A white whipped topping and light nutmeg dusting finish the sheet cake. Boxed cake mix keeps the starting steps simple, and there are no separate layers to stack. Make it ahead so the filling settles before slicing for your dessert table.

Prepare this eggnog poke cake.

22. Eggnog Jam

Eggnog JamPin

This eggnog jam is a custard-style spread made with egg yolks, cornstarch, butter, vanilla, and nutmeg. It has no fruit or pectin, and its creamy texture firms as it chills. Cook it gently on the stove, then refrigerate rather than treating it as a shelf-stable preserve. Spoon some onto bread or use it alongside holiday bakes.

Try this eggnog jam.

23. Eggnog Tiramisu

Eggnog TiramisuPin

Soft ladyfingers alternate with fluffy eggnog mascarpone cream in this chilled dessert. A little bourbon warms the eggnog dipping mixture, while whipped cream, cinnamon, and nutmeg finish the top. The overnight rest lets the biscuits soften into the filling. With no baking required, this is a useful choice when you want dessert ready before guests arrive.

Layer this eggnog tiramisu.

24. Spiced Eggnog Oatmeal Cream Pies

Spiced Eggnog Oatmeal Cream PiesPin

Chewy oatmeal cookies sandwich a eggnog buttercream in these cream pies. Cinnamon flavors the cookies, and nutmeg connects the filling with the dough. Eggnog goes into the buttercream rather than the cookie batter, keeping the texture balanced. Cool the cookies before sandwiching so the centers stay in place when you pick them up.

Make these spiced eggnog oatmeal cream pies.

25. Eggnog Sugar Cookie Bars

Eggnog Sugar Cookie BarsPin

Thick sugar cookie dough presses into a baking dish for these bars. Eggnog and nutmeg flavor the base, and a creamy eggnog frosting spreads over the slab. There is no dough rolling or cutting out shapes, which keeps preparation simple. Slice into squares after frosting for a dessert tray or a serving with coffee.

Bake these eggnog sugar cookie bars.

26. Eggnog Scones

Eggnog SconesPin

Cold butter gives these scones tender centers and golden edges, while eggnog flavors both the dough and glaze. A gentle hand keeps the mixture from becoming tough, and the thick drizzle adds sweetness after baking. Serve a wedge with coffee or arrange smaller portions among holiday sweets. The finish leaves the crumb easy to enjoy.

Try these glazed eggnog scones.

Final Thoughts

Choosing a few eggnog desserts is easier when you think about how you want to serve them. Bars, cookies, and fudge fit a shared tray, while cheesecake, trifle, and cream pie give you something to bring out after dinner. For a warm dessert, bread pudding or a freshly baked soufflé offers a different texture.

Check chilling and rising times before choosing your recipe, especially during a busy holiday week. A dessert made the day before can make serving feel calmer. Start with the flavor and texture you enjoy most, then keep another recipe nearby for the rest of the carton.

About

Millie Pham

Hi there! I'm Millie Pham, a devoted brewer and tea lover at heart. As the founder of Bean Leaf Cup, my mission is to share my tea and coffee expertise with you all. I firmly believe that creating a fantastic cup of tea or coffee should be easy for everyone. No matter if you're already a coffee or tea expert or just beginning your journey, I'm here to help you navigate the world of brewing. Welcome aboard!